Blackjack is one of the few beatable games on the casino floor, provided that you play optimally and use techniques that give you a mathematical advantage over the house. Card counting is the most widely used method to achieve this. Savvy players have been using it with great success at land-based casinos for the last seven decades.
This raises an important question: is this strategy applicable at online casinos with live dealers, and if so, is it effective? The following article covers the topic in detail. Before we address its effectiveness, we will briefly explain what card counting is and how it works.
Card Counting Basics
First things first, card counting is a form of advantage play rather than a cheating technique and as such, it is perfectly okay from a legal perspective. It gives players an idea of the composition of the remaining deck(s), i.e. the ratio of high to low cards that remain to be dealt. A deck or shoe rich in low cards favors the house, while more high cards work to the advantage of players.
Counters use this knowledge to size their wagers proportionately. They bet less or nothing when at a disadvantage and increase their stakes when the remaining cards favor them. Contrary to popular belief, there is no need to be a savant or excel at math to count cards. The only requirement is to have some basic knowledge of addition, subtraction, and division.
Card Values
Counters assign values to the cards based on their denomination but these count values can differ based on the counting system one uses. The system we recommend is called the Hi-Lo where high-denomination cards are counted as -1 and low ones are valued at +1. The third group comprises neutral cards (7, 8, and 9) – these do not have any count value since they favor neither the house nor the player.
| Card Denomination | Assigned Value under Hi-Lo System |
|---|---|
| Ace, Jack, King, Queen, Ten | -1 |
| 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 | 1 |
| 7, 8, 9 | 0 |
The Running Count
Players add or subtract the corresponding values of each dealt card to maintain a running count that indicates the current composition of the remaining deck. The table below demonstrates how this works and as you can see, we end the round with a running count of -3.
| Dealt Card | Current Running Count |
|---|---|
| Ace | -1 |
| Jack | -2 |
| King | -3 |
| 2 | -2 |
| 7 | -2 |
| 3 | -1 |
| Queen | -2 |
| 9 | -2 |
| 10 | -3 |
The True Count
Multi-deck games, such as those available at live dealer casinos, require one additional step. You must convert your running count into a true count. The true count is the current running count divided by the number of remaining decks in play, rounded to the nearest half deck. For instance, a running count of -3 with 2.5 decks remaining yields a true count of -1.
Bet Sizing Based on Count
As the true count increases, the player’s advantage grows, which calls for raising the bet. Bet sizing should be proportionate to the current true count and the player’s edge. Many players calculate their wagers by subtracting one base betting unit from the true count. For example, if you use $20 as your base unit and reach a true count of +3, you should bet two base units, or $40 in total.
So Can You Effectively Count Cards at Live Dealer Casinos?
1Unfavorable Table Conditions
The short answer is no. Card counting is theoretically possible at live dealer casinos, but unfavorable table conditions make it ineffective in practice. Live casino operators are also familiar with the technique and take every possible precaution to protect themselves from card counters.
2Unfavorable Rules Grind Down Your Advantage
You need player-friendly conditions when counting cards for the strategy to pay off. If the rules are very poor, card counting will not be enough to help you beat the game. Rules such as no resplitting, no doubling after a split, and allowing doubles only on totals of 9, 10, or 11 are too disadvantageous for card counters to overcome.
Blackjack payouts of 6 to 5 are also offered at some live dealer tables, further worsening the situation for advantage players. The vast majority of live tables use eight decks, which significantly erodes card counters’ edge.
3Too Few Rounds per Hour
No matter how skilled you are at counting, you will not see adequate returns in terms of expected value unless you play enough rounds per hour. Counting cards at live dealer tables is generally not worth your while because of the incredibly slow pace of play. Tables are often full, and you have to wait for other players to make their decisions.
There are also intervals between rounds (approximately 13 seconds) for players to place their next bets, which further slows the action. Successful counters normally play at least a hundred rounds per hour, but the most you can manage at online live dealer tables is fifty rounds per hour. This snail’s pace erodes your hourly expected value and makes counting a waste of time.
4Insufficient Shoe Penetration
Card counting is only effective if the dealer provides adequate deck or shoe penetration, i.e. they must deal enough cards before the reshuffle. This is not the case at online live casinos, where blackjack dealers usually reshuffle in the middle of the shoe at best. With eight decks in play, the best you can hope for is four-deck penetration.
For reference, dealing four out of six decks in a six-deck game is considered poor penetration. Savvy counters look for dealers who show at least four and a half to five decks at six-deck tables. Accordingly, a live dealer must show at least six and a half or seven out of eight decks to provide adequate penetration in eight-deck games.
Needless to say, this never happens. It is theoretically possible to extract some value under such conditions. However, you will generate minuscule hourly profits because you will rarely see high positive counts. The bottom line is you will be better off collecting aluminum cans for recycling than playing live eight-deck blackjack with 50% penetration.
5Continuous Shuffle Machines
Gaining an advantage by counting cards becomes completely impossible at live blackjack tables that use continuous shuffle machines (CSMs). Dealers in these games deal a few rounds, collect the discards, and load them back into the machine for a reshuffle. The CSM constantly shuffles the decks, making it impossible to track the cards and count effectively.
Continuous shufflers are bad news for both counters and basic strategy players. They speed up the pace of the game because the dealer never pauses for a manual reshuffle. Basic strategy players therefore go through more hands per hour at a disadvantage, losing more money in the long term.
Online Casinos Do Not Tolerate Advantage Play
1Specific Clauses in T&C
Similar to land-based gambling businesses, live dealer casinos frown on advantage play (AP) and have little tolerance for card counters. In addition to the countermeasures described above, online operators include specific clauses in their terms and conditions to protect themselves from advantage players.
2Live Dealer Casinos Refuse Service to AP Customers
Live casino operators reserve the right to refuse service to players suspected of using techniques that allow them to circumvent the house advantage built into the games. An excerpt from PlayOJO’s terms of use states that the casino reserves the right to partially or fully withhold the balance of customers who engage in prohibited practices. By ‘prohibited practices’, the operator means the following:
“[…] Frauds, cheating and collusion practices which are used in the gambling and gaming industry (including but not limited to ‘Wonging’, ‘Perfect Pair’ card counting, Dragon Tiger ‘Suited Tie’ card counting, and any other card counting techniques)[…].”
This is just one example, as most online gambling companies take the same stance.
Apart from withholding the winnings associated with counting, players might have their accounts terminated and their deposits retained in favor of the casino.
3The Casino Software Also Tracks the Cards
Live casino software enables online operators to closely monitor gameplay and track all cards dealt at the live blackjack tables. Avoiding detection while card counting is difficult because the strategy requires you to frequently vary your bets. Casinos look for these irregular betting patterns and use them to quickly identify advantage players.
What You Can Do Instead of Card Counting
Now that it is clear card counting is largely ineffective at live dealer casinos, the question arises: what can online players do to improve their situation? There are several ways to achieve this, including using perfect basic strategy, choosing variations with favorable rules, and managing your bankroll properly.
Use Perfect Basic Strategy
Learning perfect basic strategy before joining the live blackjack tables is the most effective step you can take. It gives you the optimal play for every hand based on your starting total and the dealer’s exposed card. Basic strategy helps you shave off some of the house advantage, increases your win rate, and reduces your long-term losses.
Strategy charts are freely available online. If you find it difficult to memorize all the moves, you can download and print a chart for reference while playing at a live dealer casino. Online gambling operators allow their customers to use basic strategy, which is not the case with card counting. Follow the chart consistently on every hand that is dealt to you.
Scout for Tables with Lower House Edges
Online players have better chances of winning at live dealer blackjack when they select variations with lower house edges. You can do this by playing at tables with more player-friendly conditions, since each rule either increases or reduces the house advantage. Examine the two variants below and you will quickly see what we mean.
Manage Your Bankroll Adequately
Managing your funds wisely always pays off, especially when it comes to gambling. Set aside a bankroll reserved solely for playing live blackjack and be disciplined enough to stick to it. First, determine how much money you need per session and bet in proportion to your session bankroll.
If you have a limited amount at your disposal, play at tables with lower limits instead of overbetting your bankroll. Finally, if you want your session bankroll to last longer, look for full or nearly full live tables where the game runs more slowly, allowing you to play fewer hands per hour.